Elliptical trainer vs. treadmill vs. stationary bike

The number of people who choose to exercise at home is booming, but because of space and money limits, most people can only afford one equipment.

If you want to get a good cardio workout, you might debate between an elliptical trainer, treadmill, and stationary cycle.

There isn’t a terrible option here because each will provide an excellent cardiovascular exercise.

Treadmills allow you to burn the most calories per hour if you push yourself, while ellipticals and exercise cycles are lower-impact options that put less strain on your joints and reduce your risk of injury.

Bicycles that remain stationary

You may pedal like you would on a bicycle from the comfort and safety of your own home using stationary bikes.

Stationary bikes are wonderful for not only boosting your overall fitness, but they may also help you increase your fitness for cycling in the real world when you can’t get outside on your bike.

Riding a stationary bike is a terrific cardio workout that raises your heart rate while boosting your cardiovascular health and lung capacity, as well as a great leg workout.

Pros of stationary bikes

A stationary bike is a low-impact activity that is less taxing on the joints than running.

While stationary bikes target your legs and glutes, if you stand up on your pedals and focus your core, they may also train your upper body.


Switching the resistance on a stationary bike to meet your exercise level and goals is simple.

Disadvantages of stationary bicycles

The seats are a tad uncomfortable, especially if you plan on working out for longer than 30 minutes.
Unless you push yourself hard, stationary bikes burn the fewest calories per hour of all the bikes, ellipticals, and treadmills.

Stationary bikes that are the best

The NordicTrack S22i Studio Cycle is unbeatable if you’re searching for a high-end gym-quality workout cycle.

It has a huge touchscreen that allows you to join in large studio exercises from the comfort of your own home.

Is an elliptical trainer, treadmill, or stationary cycle right for you?

This depends on your exercise objectives and health requirements. If calorie burning potential is your primary concern, running on a treadmill allows you to burn the most calories per hour.

Elliptical trainers and stationary bikes are preferable than treadmills for those with knee difficulties or other joint concerns who are concerned about high-impact training.

It’s worth mentioning that treadmills and stationary cycles provide little in the way of upper-body strength, so supplement your workout with some weights.

You should be able to figure out which option is best for you now that you know more about each one.

Elliptical trainers are elliptical trainers.

Elliptical trainers are a cross between a treadmill and a stairmaster; the stepping motion is like that of a stationary bike, but in an upright position.

On an elliptical machine, you work your arms, chest, back, and shoulders, as well as your leg muscles and glutes, because you move both your arms and legs.

Pros of elliptical trainers

An elliptical trainer, according to Healthline, is a low-impact exercise that is suitable for persons who have knee or other joint problems.

Ellipticals can deliver a full-body exercise if you engage your core and pump your arms hard enough.

Even those who are new to working out can use elliptical machines because they are simple to operate.

Because the resistance can be adjusted, you may simply offer yourself a more strenuous or relaxing workout as desired.

Cons of using an elliptical trainer

An elliptical trainer’s movement pattern isn’t the same as what you’d do in real life, so while it can help you get in shape, it won’t help you train for real-life events.

It’s easy to zone out on an elliptical machine and not put in as much work as you should because it’s so simple to use.

The most effective elliptical trainers

The NordicTrack FS10i is our top recommendation if you’re searching for a high-quality elliptical trainer that won’t break the bank.

It comes with a 10-inch screen for watching studio workouts, as well as a one-year iFit membership.

The Nautilus E618 Elliptical is another excellent option that will provide you with a terrific workout at a reduced cost.

Treadmills

If you enjoy running but cannot do so because of inclement weather, family obligations, or live in a location that is not conducive to running, a treadmill is an excellent option.

You can simply change the pace from a gentle walk to a sprint, which is great for folks who are starting back into exercise after an accident or who are building up their fitness from scratch.

You can even vary the incline on some treadmills to imitate uphill running.

Pros of using a treadmill

Treadmills provide you a lot of control over your workout because you can quickly vary the speed and slope, making them ideal for high-intensity interval training.

Treadmills work all of your leg muscles, as well as your glutes and hip flexors.

Because treadmills replicate real-world action (walking and running), after you’ve mastered treadmill running, it is simple to transition to road or trail running.

The disadvantages of using a treadmill

Treadmill running is a high-impact activity that can cause shin splints, knee ailments, and other joint problems.

A treadmill does not provide an effective upper-body workout.

Because of its extensive list of high-end features, the NordicTrack X32i is our overall best treadmill. For those on a tighter budget, the XTERRA Fitness TR150 is a pleasant alternative.

Leave a Comment