Elliptical Or Treadmill: Which Is Better And Which To Choose?

When, for organizational reasons or for lack of time, you decide to continue to keep fit not in the gym.

 You need to choose equipment that can optimize your workouts , in a small space such as that of a house.

The doubt, for example, could concern which to choose between treadmill and Best Elliptical For Fibromyalgia , two machines that allow you to perform complete workouts, but which adapt to different goals and needs.

Each of them, in fact, has advantages and disadvantages depending on the used to be made of it. 

The exercises with both are aerobic and this means that it is possible to strengthen the muscles, but also to make the cardiocirculatory and respiratory systems work properly.

Apart from this, however, between the treadmill and the elliptical bike (or cross-trainer) there are significant differences that must be considered when deciding to make this type of purchase, also because in a home the space is not always available. ‘one for the other.

The choice, therefore, depends on some preliminary considerations that must be made, especially as regards the objectives to be achieved.

In this article, therefore, we will try to shed some light on the differences between the Best Elliptical For Weight Loss or the treadmill.


Better the elliptical or the treadmill?

Better the elliptical or the treadmill?

To answer this question, it is necessary to ask another: what training goal do you want to achieve?

 In fact, both machines are efficient and effective, but in two different areas.

As mentioned, the exercises are of the aerobic type , i.e. the physical effort made is moderate but lasts overtime for which the body draws a general benefit, both for what concerns the muscles concerned and for losing fat and heart function. .

That said, however, there are significant differences to consider before purchasing.

To lose weight

If the primary need is to lose weight , both the elliptical and the treadmill may be fine.

 Prolonged effort over time, in fact, affects the body ‘s fat reserves (be it on the stomach , hips or other points of the body), .

It is advisable to set programs with constant activity for at least 20 minutes.

I can do this both with the mat and with the elliptical bike, but while with the first you can only run or walk, with the second you can use different muscle groups , also toning the torso and arms, impossible to do with a treadmill.

The training for weight loss done with the elliptical bike , therefore it is I consumed more complete and more calories at the same time. 

Of course, I should emphasize that, in all cases, we must always associate physical exercise with a healthy and balanced diet.

To strengthen the musculature

The mat simulates running or walking for which the training is done on the leg muscles, with a significant strengthening of the muscles of the thighs, calves, ankles and buttocks , especially when setting a slope.

Someone can also do perfectly this with the elliptical , avoiding going to grip the handlebars. 

In addition, in this case, it will force the body to seek the right balance, also affecting the abdominal muscles .

If you grab the dumbbells, the back and arm muscles will work harder.

 It should be considered that, even if more tiring,  specific training for running can only be done with a carpet.

Impact on the joints

Incorrect use of the treadmill could lead, over time, to suffer from problems affecting the joints of the lower limbs and back.

This is because the impact with the surface goes to stress the spine, ankles and knees, even if in a lighter way than the ground of a road.

For this reason, experts always recommend wearing shoes with adequate cushioning and never using the carpet barefoot even for walking.

In the elliptical bike, this problem does not exist because a run is not simulated for which there is no collision with the plane.

 For this reason, I usually recommend the elliptical to carry out rehabilitation after an injury, with physiotherapy or to maintain mobility in elderly people.

Price and practicality

After having verified how the elliptical trainer and the treadmill are both useful tools for keeping fit and toning the muscles, albeit with the various differences.

We must also evaluate the price and size, two important aspects that could often lead to opting for one rather than for the other.

A carpet with excellent performance , performing and with high-quality materials has a price that can vary from 450 euros up to 1500 euros depending on the options and features.

Most of them are now designed to be folded and stored in small spaces.

The elliptical bike has prices starting from 200 euros up to 2000 euros for the most complete and professional ones. 

Most of the models take up less space than a rug and can also be folded away when not in use.

For having to buy a useful tool for indoor training, the choice often boils down to two great classics: elliptical or treadmill?

In the next few lines, we will focus on these two products: we will tell you about their chief characteristics, benefits and disadvantages, then comparing them.

We know the elliptical

The elliptical is an interesting fitness tool because it combines the movement of the cross-country ski with the trajectory traveled by the feet during the race .

Its structure makes this possible precisely: first, a single transmission allows the pedals , which guarantee the training of the muscles of the lower part, and the mobile handlebars that take care of those of the upper part, to move simultaneously and alternate.

Despite this feature, however, training does not have to be carried out, always involving both the legs and the arms. 

If you have problems with your wrists, hands, elbows or shoulders, in fact, you can maintain a stable support using a third handlebar , this time fixed and central , working only with the lower part of the body.

In addition, you can count on the presence of a heart rate monitor , an electrical control center and a display through which you can always monitor your physical parameters and those related to training such as slope , speed , distance traveled. And calories burned .


The benefits of the elliptical

The elliptical can also guarantee you the inclusion of significant benefits in your routine, not only sports but also daily.

First, muscle toning . Legs, thighs, buttocks, abdomen, back, shoulders, arms and forearms are stimulated in a targeted manner. 

After a few months of constant training, you will notice a noticeable improvement in the firming of the muscles that you have stressed the most.

Since the elliptical is a tool that allows you to perform a so-called cardio workout , it affects the cardiovascular and circulatory systems , you will notice net benefits also in these aspects. 

It will also improve your breathing and your resistance to exertion , as well as your aerobic metabolism .

As always happens for physical activity of any kind, we should not underestimate the psychological benefits that are also based on the decrease in cortisol and the consequent increase in serotonin .

However, the greatest advantage of the elliptical is that it is very gentle on the joints and, especially, the ankles and knees, will not suffer from the trauma caused by rebound stress . 

This is made possible because the feet never come off the pedals and that the movement is guided.

The elliptical can also contribute to your weight loss even if, to get satisfactory results from this point of view, accumulate the intensity of the workouts, changing the parameters relating to the slope and resistance.

I used the treadmill a lot, both in gyms and in domestic environments. 

It is essentially a substitute for running, which can, however, be done indoors, a fundamental feature when it is raining or windy outside.

It is a tool formed by a conveyor belt on which to walk or run.

By two fixed handlebars you can lean on and by an intuitive and technologically advanced display.

The effort during training can be more or less intense depending on how you decide to adjust speed and slope .

 All these parameters can always be monitored and changed via the display; besides slope and speed.

You will also have under control the duration of the workout , the calories , the distance you have covered and, if they equip the dumbbells with a heart rate monitor , your heart rate will also be present .

Training on the treadmill also gives you the possibility to choose between programs already set for you which, together with a warm-up and final cool down , provide for a controlled increase in speed and incline.

The benefits of the treadmill

Training on the treadmill can be especially beneficial.

Besides improving your aerobic endurance , cardio training on this machine leads to improvements that affect the cardiovascular and respiratory systems .

It helps with toning of lower body muscles and increases oxygenation of the heart and other tissues.

Even the balance will be affected absolutely positively, not to mention a fairly high weight loss potential.

 The treadmill contributes to a decrease in stress levels and an increase in psychological well-being .

This very famous tool owes much of its fame not only to its practicality of use , but also to a system capable of absorbing shock and microtraumas at the level of the joints.

Elliptical versus treadmill: which one to choose?

As we have seen, especially in the paragraphs dedicated to the benefits of both tools, the differences are not substantial.

 Both the elliptical trainer and the treadmill help improve oxygenation, balance, breathing, endurance and metabolism .

Although the treadmill has a greater slimming effect, starting from the first workouts, the elliptical will also bring you those same results.

 You will first have to familiarize yourself with the machine and escalate the intensity.

Both the elliptical and the treadmill are tools designed not to burden the joints , but in this case, the elliptical is clearly superior, thanks to the fact that the movement does not involve any impact. 

If you want to carry out a workout that is as complete as possible, the elliptical is the right choice .

 You can thus stimulate the lower muscles together with the upper ones, a feature that does not belong to the treadmill, oriented only to the work of the lower part.

Buying a treadmill is rather much cheaper , while the elliptical can get to involve an expenditure of almost $ 1,500. 

The elliptical, however, allows for a different and slightly better training

Especially if you want to take care of firming your whole body, they will amply reward this higher economic investment.

Finally, the space factor . In fact, the elliptical is very bulky . The treadmill is too , as the two structures are quite similar to each other. 

But the latter is also available in some folding models , capable of carrying the tape up to the handlebars. 

The treadmill can thus be a little less bulky than an elliptical.



In short, therefore, whoever has to decide which tool to buy must keep in mind that an elliptical has the advantages of taking up little space .

It allows complete movements by training various groups of muscles (especially for the possibility of performing a reverse pedaling), has beneficial effects on the cardiovascular system and can be easily used even by poorly trained people .

The treadmill allows you to run or walk, so it is perfect for those who prefer to jog or train for a race , focuses on strengthening the leg muscles, can have a negative impact on the joints and should be used carefully, but as well.

It has excellent results on the heart and vascular system.

The choice depends only on you , but in case of doubts, it is always advisable to contact your doctor or specialized personnel.

We relate the purchase to rehabilitation or if you have particular pathologies.

Leave a Comment